We’ll increase conversions by


on your website.

Get a FREE Audit today
See how we can help your business increase conversion rates

Common Mistakes To Avoid When Hiring An SEO Consultant

In today’s competitive digital landscape, hiring an SEO consultant has become a crucial step for businesses seeking to thrive online. However, with so many consultants offering their services, it’s easy to make mistakes when choosing the right one for your company.

In this blog post, we’ll discuss some common pitfalls you should avoid and provide tips on selecting the ideal SEO expert who aligns with your industry and goals.

Understanding The Importance Of Hiring An SEO Consultant

The digital landscape is ever-evolving, making it crucial for businesses to stay updated with the latest trends and best practices. In this competitive environment, having a solid SEO strategy in place can make all the difference in driving organic traffic and increasing online visibility.

As your business grows and expands into new markets or product lines, it becomes even more vital to have an experienced SEO consultant on board who can help you maintain a strong presence in search engine results pages (SERPs).

Ignoring the importance of hiring an expert SEO consultant could lead to several unwanted consequences like lost opportunities for revenue generation and unnecessary spending on ineffective marketing tactics.

For instance, choosing irrelevant keywords or using outdated techniques will end up tanking your website’s ranking on SERPs.

It cannot be stressed enough how critical open communication channels between both parties are when working with an SEO consultant since both client-side expectations and recommendations from the specialist should align seamlessly for long-term success.

Top Mistakes To Avoid When Hiring An SEO Consultant

Believing unrealistic promises, falling for “special tools” or guarantees and overlooking expertise are some of the common mistakes that businesses make when hiring an SEO consultant.

Believing Unrealistic Promises

One common hiring mistake when searching for an SEO consultant is believing in unrealistic promises. Some consultants may claim to deliver top search rankings within a very short time or guarantee specific results that seem too good to be true.

It’s crucial to remember that Search Engine Optimization (SEO) is a long-term strategy, and attaining concrete outcomes usually takes time, effort, and consistent monitoring.

To avoid making this mistake during your selection process, always engage in thorough research on any potential SEO consultant’s background, skills, and accomplishments. Look for documented success stories from past clients as well as proven expertise in current industry best practices.

Falling For “Special Tools” Or Guarantees

In the competitive world of SEO, some consultants may try to entice potential clients by promoting “special tools” or guarantees that promise quick success. These offers can be alluring, especially to business owners who are eager to see immediate results from their investment in search engine optimization.

However, it’s crucial to remember that there is no magic bullet for achieving top rankings overnight.

Falling for these unrealistic promises can lead not only to wasted resources but also potential damage to your website’s reputation with search engines. For example, employing black hat techniques—such as buying large quantities of low-quality backlinks or keyword-stuffing—may deliver short-term gains but could ultimately result in penalties from Google and other search engines.

Hiring Based On Keyword Ranking Promises

One of the biggest mistakes to avoid when hiring an SEO consultant is basing your decision on keyword ranking promises. Many SEOs may try to sell you on specific keywords that they can rank for, but this doesn’t guarantee success in terms of driving traffic or conversions.

In fact, focusing too much on certain keywords can actually lead to a decline in overall rankings if it leads to producing low-quality content or spammy tactics.

Overlooking Expertise And Experience

One of the biggest mistakes to avoid when hiring an SEO consultant is overlooking their expertise and experience. It’s not uncommon for businesses to work with individuals or companies that dabble in SEO, but have another area of competence.

Only a true expert with extensive knowledge of SEO can help your business rise through the ranks on search engines. Working with someone who knows nothing about SEO could end up costing you time, money, and resources without producing any worthwhile results.

Being Locked In With Long-term Contracts

One common mistake to avoid when hiring an SEO consultant is being locked into long-term contracts. While it may seem like a good idea to sign on for a longer commitment to ensure better results, it can actually be detrimental in the long run.

This is because search engines constantly update their algorithms, and strategies that work today may not work tomorrow. If you’re locked into a contract with an SEO consultant who cannot adapt to these changes, you’ll be stuck paying for ineffective services.

For example, say you hire an SEO agency on a two-year contract basis but find out after six months that they are using outdated tactics that are no longer effective due to algorithm updates made by Google during this time period.

Unfortunately, since you’re locked into the contract for another 18 months or so with this agency, there’s nothing much you can do except continue paying them without seeing any real progress towards your goals.

How To Choose The Right SEO Consultant

To ensure that you choose the right SEO consultant for your business, it is important to evaluate their proven results, communication skills, pricing and contracts, as well as transparency and communication – keep reading to learn more.

Look For Proven Results And Experience

Experience is one of the most critical factors when it comes to selecting an SEO consultant. Look for someone who has a proven track record in the industry and a history of achieving real results for their clients.

Proven results should also be at the top of your list when evaluating potential SEO consultants. Don’t let flashy promises distract you from what really matters: metrics such as increased organic traffic and improved search engine rankings.

Get References And Check Them

Before hiring an SEO consultant, it is crucial to dig deeper and check their references. This step allows you to ensure that you are working with an experienced consultant who can deliver successful projects. Here’s how to get references and check them:

  1. Ask for a list of the consultant’s previous clients and look for reviews or testimonials online.
  2. Contact the references given by the consultant and ask about their experience working with them.
  3. Inquire about the results delivered, communication skills, and professionalism of the consultant.
  4. Pay particular attention to clients in your industry, as they can provide valuable insights into whether the consultant can handle your specific needs.
  5. Check with professional associations or trade groups to confirm that the SEO agency holds a good reputation within its specific industry.

Investing time in getting references and checking them gives you confidence that you have chosen an SEO expert who has a proven record of success and delivers long-term value for your business.

Evaluate Communication Skills

Effective communication is essential when hiring an SEO consultant. A good consultant should be able to explain technical details in a way that even the most novice business owner can understand.

They should be willing to listen to your concerns, questions, and feedback and provide responses that are thorough and helpful. In addition, they should demonstrate exceptional writing skills if they are responsible for drafting content or optimizing pages on your website.

Moreover, communication also involves how frequently you will receive updates regarding progress or changes made by the consultant during the project duration. There must be clear guidelines as to what milestones will be achieved before providing updates so both parties know what to expect at every stage of the process.

Consider Pricing And Contracts

Pricing and contracts are crucial factors to consider when hiring an SEO consultant. Some consultants may offer their services at a lower price point, but it is important to make sure you’re not sacrificing quality for cost.

A higher price point may mean that the consultant has more experience and a proven track record in delivering results for their clients. Additionally, pay attention to the contract details such as length of engagement or termination clauses.

It’s important to have transparency with your SEO consultant from the beginning so there are no surprises later on down the line.

Check For Transparency And Communication

One of the critical factors to consider when hiring an SEO consultant is transparency and communication. A good SEO consultant should be open about their methods, strategies, and results.

They should be willing to answer any questions you have and provide regular updates on the progress of your project.

To avoid potential issues in the future with your enterprise SEO expert, it’s essential to have clear communication throughout the process. Ask for regular reports detailing work done and proposed next steps for improvement.

A reputable consultant will offer detailed explanations regarding their methodology as well as advice on how best to approach any roadblocks encountered during optimization efforts.

Red Flags To Watch Out For When Hiring An SEO Consultant

When hiring an SEO consultant, it’s important to be aware of red flags such as promises of quick results or buying backlinks.

Promising Quick Results

One of the red flags to watch out for when hiring an SEO consultant is the promise of quick results. While everyone wants their website to quickly climb the Google rankings, this is not always a realistic expectation.

A reputable SEO consultant will explain that effective optimization takes time and effort, and that there are no magic tricks or shortcuts.

In fact, promising fast results can actually be harmful in itself as it means the focus would be on short-term gains rather than long-term growth.

Offering A “One-size-fits-all” Package

One of the biggest mistakes businesses make when hiring an SEO consultant is falling for companies that offer a “one-size-fits-all” package. This approach might seem convenient, but it’s not suitable for every business.

Different industries have different target markets, goals and objectives; therefore, they require different strategies to show up on search engine result pages (SERPs). For instance, a small local business selling shoes online will have different SEO needs than an e-commerce company specializing in pet products at the regional or national level.

Overpromising And Under Delivering

One of the biggest red flags to watch out for when hiring an SEO consultant is overpromising and under delivering. Some consultants may make unrealistic promises or guarantee immediate results, leading to disappointment and wasted money in the long run.

Another way consultants can overpromise is by offering a “one-size-fits-all” package that does not consider individual business needs. Clients need tailored solutions that align with their goals and objectives for meaningful progress.

Buying Backlinks

Buying backlinks is still a common practice in SEO, but it can be detrimental to your website’s ranking if not done correctly. It is important to avoid certain red flags when doing so, such as sitewide links, link-selling services, and “red flag” websites.

It is crucial to ask potential SEO agencies about their link building methods and avoid any that offer to sell backlinks or engage in other unethical practices. Bad backlinks can harm your SEO efforts, so it is also important to identify and remove them.

Not Adhering To Best Practices

Hiring an SEO consultant who doesn’t adhere to best practices is a common mistake that can significantly harm your website’s ranking. If your hired consultant engages in black-hat techniques like hidden text and keyword stuffing, it could lead to penalization from Google or even removal from the search engine altogether.

It’s crucial to ensure that the consultant you hire follows ethical standards and uses proven methods for better rankings.

According to recent studies by Google, 75% of internet users never go past the first page of search results. Therefore, hiring an experienced SEO consultant who understands proper optimization techniques will be essential in driving traffic to your business website.

Questions To Ask Before Hiring An SEO Consultant

To make sure you choose the right SEO consultant, it’s essential to ask them specific questions such as their approach to staying current with SEO best practices, how they report and analyze their SEO work, and what kind of contract or agreement will be in place.

In What Industries Have You Worked Before?

Asking about the industries that an SEO consultant has worked with before is crucial in determining their level of expertise and familiarity with your business. Look for consultants who have experience working with businesses similar to yours, especially if you operate in a niche industry.

For example, if you run a healthcare company or law firm, you’ll want to find an SEO consultant who understands the unique challenges of these industries.

Having experience in your industry means that an SEO consultant will likely be familiar with the specific keywords and phrases commonly used by consumers within it. This knowledge can help them create tailored strategies for improving your website’s search engine ranking based on what people are searching for when looking for products or services like yours.

Can You Provide References And Case Studies?

When hiring an SEO consultant, it is important to ask for references and case studies to get a better understanding of their capabilities and track record. Here are some things to look for when evaluating references and case studies:

  1. Success stories: Look for examples where the SEO consultant has achieved significant results for their clients, such as increased website traffic or higher search engine rankings.
  2. Similar industries: Ideally, you want to work with an SEO consultant who has experience working within your industry or niche. This will give them a better understanding of your target audience and how to optimize your website accordingly.
  3. Long-term success: It’s important to choose an SEO consultant who can demonstrate long-term success with their clients rather than just short-term gains that may not last.
  4. Communication skills: In addition to asking for references and case studies, pay attention to how the SEO agency communicates with you. Do they listen actively? Are they transparent in their communication?
  5. Transparency: Choose an SEO consultant that is willing to share their methods and techniques with you, rather than keeping everything behind closed doors. This will help you avoid deceitful SEO practices or penalties down the line.

By looking at references and case studies along with effective communication skills and transparency from a potential SEO agency, you’ll be able to make a more informed decision on who best matches your needs as a client.

What Is Your Approach To Staying Current With SEO Best Practices?

To ensure their clients receive the most updated SEO strategies, a top-notch consultant must stay current with SEO best practices. This can be achieved in several ways. For instance, attending industry conferences and training events is an excellent way to keep abreast of new trends and updates across search engines.

Additionally, subscribing to relevant newsletters or other industry publications that cover algorithm changes, competitor analysis or new keyword research tools will help you stay informed.

Staying active on social media groups specializing in SEO can also offer valuable insights into what is currently happening within the industry.

Can You Provide A Detailed SEO Strategy For Long-term Success?

In order to ensure long-term success with your SEO efforts, it is important to have a detailed strategy in place that takes into account your specific business goals and objectives. When hiring an SEO consultant, it is crucial to ask if they can provide this level of detail in their approach. Here are some key elements to look for in a detailed SEO strategy:

  1. Keyword research: A comprehensive keyword research plan should be put in place to identify the most valuable and relevant keywords for your business.
  2. On-page optimization: This involves optimizing website content, Meta tags, HTML structure, and other on-page factors to make them search engine friendly.
  3. Content strategy: Your content strategy should include plans for creating high-quality content that will attract links and engagement from your target audience.
  4. Link-building tactics: An effective link-building plan will help increase the authority of your website and improve its ranking potential.
  5. Technical SEO: This includes aspects like site speed optimization, mobile responsiveness, crawlability, and structured data markup.
  6. Analytics planning: Metrics tracking is a critical component of any SEO strategy as it allows you to track progress towards your goals and make data-driven optimizations.
  7. Ongoing monitoring and reporting: Regular check-ins are needed to ensure the success of the SEO campaign over time, monitoring progress against KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) such as traffic growth, rankings improvement or revenue growth – depending on what matters most for you – so adjustments can be made where necessary.

By having a detailed plan that covers all these aspects of SEO marketing, you can feel confident that your consultant is equipped to deliver long-term success for your business.

How Do You Report And Analyze Your SEO Work?

A crucial aspect of choosing the right SEO consultant is evaluating their reporting and analysis process. As an essential part of any SEO work, reporting helps evaluate the performance and effectiveness of a campaign.

Great SEO consultants should have a transparent and comprehensive approach to presenting data that shows how their efforts are impacting organic search rankings, driving traffic, and increasing conversions.

It’s also worth noting that knowledgeable SEO consultants will be able to use data-driven insights to identify what strategies are working best for your business and make necessary adjustments accordingly.

They can create custom dashboards using sophisticated analytics tools like Google Analytics or Moz Pro that reflect vital information such as conversion rates, impressions, clicks, bounce rates among others – all geared towards ongoing optimization to boost ROI.

What Is Your Pricing And Payment Structure?

Before hiring an SEO consultant, it’s vital to understand their pricing and payment structure. Here are some common pricing models used by SEO agencies:

  1. Hourly: Some consultants charge an hourly rate for their services, usually ranging from $75 to $200 per hour.
  2. Monthly retainer: This model involves paying a fixed monthly fee for ongoing SEO services. The cost can vary widely based on the scope of the project, but is typically between $750 and $5,000 per month.
  3. Project-based: In this model, consultants charge a flat fee for completing a specific project or delivering certain results. The cost can range from a few hundred dollars to tens of thousands of dollars.
  4. Performance-based: Some SEO consultants offer payment based on achieving specific results, such as increased website traffic or higher search rankings. While this may sound appealing, be wary of overly optimistic promises and ensure that the terms are clearly defined in writing.

It’s important to carefully consider these pricing structures and assess which one best suits your goals and budget before making your final decision on hiring an SEO consultant or agency.

What Kind Of Contract Or Agreement Will We Have In Place?

It is crucial to clarify the type of contract or agreement that will be in place before hiring an SEO consultant. The terms and conditions can vary depending on the scope of the project, budget, timeline, and other factors.

Some common types include a monthly retainer, project-based fee, or hourly rate. It’s important to discuss payment schedules and any potential extra costs upfront as well to avoid surprises down the line.

Additionally, outlining specific deliverables and timelines within the contract can ensure that both parties are on the same page about expectations for results and progress updates.


In conclusion, hiring an SEO consultant is a critical step towards boosting your online presence and growing your business. However, it’s important to avoid common mistakes that can cost you time and money. Don’t be swayed by unrealistic promises, special tools or guarantees, keyword ranking promises, or long-term contracts without vetting the consultant first. To choose the right SEO consultant for your business, assess their expertise and experience, ask for references, evaluate their communication skills and pricing structure, and ensure they adhere to best practices. Remember to watch out for red flags like offering quick results or buying backlinks. Finally, make sure to ask key questions before hiring an SEO consultant to set expectations for long-term success. With these tips in mind, you’ll be well on your way to finding the right SEO consultant for your business needs.


Hi, I’m Kurt Philip, the founder & CEO of Convertica. I live and breathe conversion rate optimization. I hope you enjoy our findings.

We’ve worked with over 1000 businesses in the last 6 years.
Let’s jump on a quick call to see how we can help yours.

Book FREE CRO Call

Client Case Studies

Follow us on Youtube